Click titles for production photos, all photos by Jim McLaughlin (McLaughlin Photography)
2021 Season
- Slow Food by Wendy Macleod
- Traffic and Weather by Martha Banta and Adam Schlesinger
- Minding Miss Mae Mae by Phillip Christian Smith
- PB&J Cafe: Cinderella Goes Disco by Shubert Fendrich
2019 Season (25th Anniversary)
- Calling All Kates by Emily Goodson & Jeremy Schonfeld
- The Enlightenment of Percival Von Schmootz by Kooman & Dimond
- Sequence by Arun Lakra
- Beau by Douglas Lyons
- PB&J Cafe: Alice in Wonderland
- Jonathan Burns Flexible Comedy
- ATF’s Greatest Hits
- Start Again by Nikko Benson
2018 Season
- Some Lovers by Steven Sater & Burt Bacharach
- Loch Ness by Marshall Pailet & AD Penedo
- The Jedi Handbook by Stephen Massicotte
- Front Page Flo by Larry Kass, Sara Kass, & George Pinney
- On Your Marc (film festival special event)
- Calling All Kates by Emily Goodson & Jeremy Schonfel (a concert reading)
- The Magic Bar
- PB&J Cafe: Robin Hood (Dinner Theatre for Kids)
2017 Season
- Nikola Tesla Drops the Beat by Nikko Benson & Benjamin Halstead
- Knights of the Sales Office by Hank Greene
- The Boy in the Bathroom by Michael Lluberes & Joe Maloney
- Glitches in Reality starring Simon Coronel
- Vienna Juvenile Sketch Comedy
- The Song of Bernadette Cabaret by Frank Wildhorn and Robin Lerner
- Big Babies by Matthew Wilkas (new play reading)
- PB&J Cafe: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe (Dinner Theatre for Kids)
2016 Season
- Island Song by Carner & Gregor
- A Comedy of Manors by Zoe Samuels
- Home by Christy Hall & Scott Alan
- Everything in Its Place: The Life and Slimes of Marc Summers by Alex Brightman & Drew Gasparini
- The Uncivil War Cabaret
- Carner & Gregor Cabaret
- Thirty Day Mourning Period (or the Revolution That Occured When Mr. Clyborne Killed Himself and Thus Was Unable to Come in to Work Thursday Morning) by Hank Greene (new play reading)
- PB&J Cafe: Stuart Little (Dinner Theatre for Kids)
2015 Season
- Kalamazoo by Michelle Kholos Brooks & Kelly Younger
- The unCivil War by Rick Kunzi, Adam Barnosky, & Justin Zeppa
- Spun: A Brother/Sister Rock Musical by Emily Goodson & Jeremy Schonfeld
- Think Again: An Evening of Mind Reading and Magic with Max Major
- Cabaret with Jeremy Schonfeld
- Cabaret with Robert J. Spencer
- The Banana Tree by Dan Castellaneta & Deb Lacusta (new play reading)
- PB&J Cafe: The True Story of the Three Little Pigs! (Dinner Theatre for Kids)
2014 Season (20th Anniversary)
- Fully Committed by Becky Mode
- Spontaneous Broadway by MopCo
- The Whale by Samuel D. Hunter
- Ring Of Fire: The Music Of Johnny Cash created by Richard Maltby, Jr. and conceived by William Meade
- People Watching (Second Act Cabaret) with Noah Zachary
- Lady Liberty And The Donut Girl by Eric Lane (new play reading)
2013 Season
- Heartbreaker: Two Months with Judy Garland by John Meyer (world premiere)
- Filming O’Keeffe by Eric Lane (world premiere)
- Avenue Q by Robert Lopez, Jeff Marx and Jeff Whitty
- Guitars Not Guns (Second Act Cabaret) with David Finch
- The Bailey’s Crossroads Opportunity School by Hal Corley (new play reading)
2012 Season
- Black Tie by A.R. Gurney
- Next to Normal by Tom Kitt (music) and Brian Yorkey (book and lyrics)
- Woody Sez: The Life and Music of Woody Guthrie devised by David Lutken with Nick Corley
- The More Things Change (second Act Cabaret) with Joe Kinosian, Kellen Blair and Anna Marquardt
- Filming O’Keeffe by Eric Lane (new play reading)
2011 Season
- The K OF D, An Urban Legend by Laura Schellhardt
- Shooting Star by Steven Dietz
- Hello Out There music by Frank Terry | book and lyrics by Eric Price (world premiere)
- Second Act Cabaret with Gary Adler Phoebe Kreutz, and Adam Armstrong
- Dream Street by Sean Christopher Lewis (a new play reading)
2010 Season
- What A Glorious Feeling book by Jay Berkow (East Coast Premiere)
- Brush The Summer By by Hal Corley (world premiere)
- Murder for Two: A Killer Musical (First Full Production) Book and lyrics by Kellen Blair book and music by Joe Kinosian (premiere)
- Loving Leo book and lyrics by Sara Cooper music by Zach Redler (a musical in progress)
- An Unexpected Evening with Howie Michael Smith With Gary Adler and Howie Michael Smith
2009 Season
- Ordinary Days by Adam Gwon
- Goat Show a solo performance written by Jennifer Fawcett
- I Will Make You Orphans written and performed by Sean C. Lewis
- Leaving Iowa by Tim Clue and Spike Manton
- Brush The Summer By a play-in-progress by Hal Corley, directed by Mark Fleischer with Peggy J. Scott and Stephen Bradbury
2008 Season
- Love Song by John Kolvenbach
- Filler Up! a solo performance written by Deb Filler and Lowry Marshall
- Altar Boyz music and lyrics by Michael Patrick Walker and Gary Adler, book by Kevin Del Aguilia, conceived by Ken Davenport and Marc Kessler
- Well I’ll Tell Ya… written and performed by Deb Filler (a work-in-progress)
2007 Season
- Behave Yourself world premiere play by Leslie Ayvazian, Directed by Martha Banta with Brenda Currin, Johanna Day, Bruce MacVittie, Hal Robinson, Joan Rosenfels, Brian Russell
- 2.5 Minute Ride a solo performance written and performed by Lisa Kron
- Tick… tick… BOOM! musical by Jonathan Larson, Directed by Gabriel BarreWith Colin Hanlon, Ryan Duncan, Sarah Glendening
- Tiny Feats of Cowardice a work-in-progress musical written and Performed by Susan Bernfield, Music by Rachel Peters
- 365 Days / 365 Plays short plays by Suzan-Lori Parks, Directed by Brenny Rabine with Sari Bobbin, David Girard, Tinashe Kajese, Tyrone Henderson, and Sue Ford
2006 Season
- All is Not by Melissa James Gibson (world premiere) Directed by Martha Banta with Haerry Kim, Mina Kim, Christopher McCann, Malcolm Morano, Rebecca Nelson, Mark Setlock, and Colleen Werthmann
- Bomb-itty of Errors a hip-hop musical by Jordan Aleen-Dutton, Jason Catalano, GQ, and Erik Weiner, Directed by Nick Corley with Jason Babinsky, Omar Evans, Benton Greene, and Jake Mosser
- A Number by Caryl Churchill, Directed by Sturgis Warner with David Barlow and Robert Lavelle
- Bad Cat a work-in-progress by Leslie Ayvazian, Directed by Martha Banta with Brenda Currin, Frank Deal, Barbara Garrick, Judith Roberts, Hal Robinson, and Peter Rini
2005 Season
- The Girl in the Frame by Jeremy Desmon, Directed by Thomas Caruso with Stephanie Kurtzuba, Vicki Van Tassel, Todd Cerveris, andVictor Wallace
- High Dive a solo play written and performed by Leslie Ayvazian
- Madagascar a play by J.T. Rogers, Directed by Gus Reyes with Mary Beth Peil, Sherri Parker Lee, and Larry Pine
- Lost a work-in-progress play by Melissa James Gibson
2004 Season
- Elaine Stritch at Liberty by Elaine Stritch and John Lahr, Originally Directed on Broadway by George C. Wolfe Musical Direction by Rob Bowman
- Boston Marriage a play by David Mamet, Directed by Martha Banta with Lise Bruneau, Megan Hollingshead, and Marina Squerciati
- Stones in His Pockets a play by Marie Jones, Directed by Jerry Manning with Kirk Jackson, and Oliver Wadsworth
- Mimi le Duck a musical by Diane Hansen-Young and Brian Feinstein (world premiere), Directed by Thomas Caruso, Musical Direction by Chris Fenwick with Robert DuSold, Allen Fitzpatrick, Annie Golden, Donald Grody, Brian Scott Johnson, Nada Rowand, Louis Tucci, and Christine Zbornik
- Coast To Coast a solo performance by Marc Wolf directed by Emily Mann
2003 Season
- The Lake’s End a play by Anton Dudley (world premiere), Directed by Martha Banta with Robert Gomes, Jason Butler Harner, Martin Kildare, Henny Russell, Anthony Veneziale
- Bingo a musical comedy by Michael Heitzman, David Holcenberg, Ilene Reid, Directed by Glenn Casale with Lisa Asher, Stacia Fernandez, Lori Fischer, Jan Leigh Herndon, Liz McCartney, Beth Malone, and Kilty Reidy.
- It Goes Without Saying a solo performance by Bill Bowers (world premiere), Directed by Martha Banta
- The Unexpected Man a play by Yasmina Reza, Directed by Jeremy Cohen with Jordan Charney and Peggy J. Scott
2002 Season
- Guys on Ice a musical by Fred Alley and James Kaplan, Directed by Martha Banta
- Fishwrap a musical review conceived by Bill Castellino and Gilles Chiasson (world premiere), Directed by Bill Castellino
- At Home in an Alien Land a play written and performed by Tyrone Mitchell Henderson (world premiere), based on the writings of Richard Wright, Directed by Martha Banta
- Blown Sideways Through Life A Play by Claudia Shear, Performed by Jennifer Perry Directed by Leigh Silverman
- New Stuff at Night
2001 Season
- Art a play by Yazmina Reza, Directed by Martha Banta, with Tyrone Henderson, Kirk Jackson, Oliver Wadsworth
- Nocturne a play by Adam Rapp, Directed by Martha Banta, Performed by Dallas Roberts
- Chrysalis a musical by Gilles Chiasson, Directed by Beth Schachter (world premiere)
- Late Night Cabaret
2000 Season
- Wit a play by Margaret Edson, Directed by Martha Banta with Mary Beth Peil, Tyron Henderson, Megan Hollingshead, Valda Setterfield, John Thomas Waite, Clay Adams, Renee Borys, Alex Goldberg, and Kelly VanZile
- The 5 & Dime Plays 10-minute plays by Joe DiPietro, Melissa James Gibson, Rick Davidson, Cathy Dede, and Robert Schulz (world premiere), Directed by Beth Schacter with Kristen Lee Kelly and Michael Mastro
- Barbara’s Blue Kitchen a musical by Lori Fischer (world premiere), Directed by Martha Banta, Musical Direction by David Lutken with Lori Fischer
- Late Night Cabaret
1999 Season
- Times Of War a play by Eric Lane (world premiere), Directed by Martha Banta with Jimmy Georgiades, David Gunderman, Maggie Low, and Jeanne Willcoxon
- Punch Me In The Stomach a solo performance by Deb Filler
- As Thousands Cheer Directed by Daisy Walker, choreographed by Schele Williams with Kenny Boys, Rosa Curry, Paul DePasquale, Laura Fois, Will Gartshore, and Cynthia Sophiea
- Acoustic Cabaret with Lori Fischer, Sean McCourt, Sean Fri, Traci Lynn Thomas, and Gilles Chiasson
1998 Season
- The Family Business a play by Ain and David Gordon, Directed by Martha Banta with Lynn Cohen, David Beach, and Tyran Grimstad
- Fully Committed a play by Becky Mode (world premiere), Directed by Phillip Shneidman with Mark Setlock
- Three Postcards a play by Craig Lucas, with music by Craig Carnelia Directed by Rachel Dickstein with P. Emma Cole, Ali Hayden, Mark Kressel, Leslie Nipkow, and Rick Oquita
- Barbara’s Blue Kitchen a musical by Lori Fischer (world premiere), Directed by Gabriel Barre with Lori Fischer, and Gilles Chiasson
- Late-Nite Cabaret – Acoustic Singer/Songwriters, with Gilles Chiasson, Lori Fischer, and Megan Carey
- Children’s Workshops led by Russell Granet and Mark Matukawitz
1997 Season
- The Deal a play by Ron Burch (world premiere), Directed by Martha Banta with Jane Young, Tim Deak, Dean Fourie, Blythe Baten, and Oliver Wadsworth
- Lucky Stiff a musical by Lynn Arhens & Stephen Flaherty, Directed by Lori Steinberg, choreographed by John Carraffa with Susan Emmerson, David Gunderman, Cynthia Sophiea, Kenny Boys, Paul DePasquale, AlDecristo, James Fall, Darren Matthias, Ali Hayden, and Sheri Sanders
- The Man in Room 306 a solo performance by Craig Allen Edwards
- Excuse My Dust a solo performance by Barbara Pitts
- Late-Nite Cabaret: Max & Maxine-The Coming Home Tour (world premiere), By and with Gary Adler, Bryan Johnson, and Jen Perry
1996 Season
- Three Tall Women a play by Edward Albee, Directed by Martha Banta with Johanna Day, Judy Frank, Lois Raebeck, and Mark Schulz
- John & Jen a musical by Andrew Lippa and Tom Greenwald, Directed by Gabriel Barre with James Bohanek, and Mary Lee Grafio
- Thin Walls a solo performance by Alice Eve Cohen
- A Fresh of Breath Air a solo performance by Dale Stein
- Late-Nite Cabaret: The Songs of Galt MacDermot (world premiere), with Mary Bond Davis, Jesse Sinclair Lenat, Cindy, and Tim Booth
1995 Season
- The Harry & Sam Dialogues a play by Karen Ellison, Directed by Martha Banta with Mark Setlock and Will Warren
- Heartbeats a musical by Amanda McBroom, Directed by John Schact, choreographed by Jennifer Krater with Gloria Ptak, Bryan Johnson, Gilles Chiasson, David Gunderman, Meg Tolin, and Jennifer Perry
- 101 Humiliating Stories a solo performance by Lisa Kron
- Prisoner in Paradise a solo performance by Stephanie Silverman
- Late-Nite Cabaret featuring the cast of Heartbeats
1994 Inaugural Benefit Performance
- Love Letters by A.R. Gurney starring Elaine Stritch and Jason Robards